THE ERUPTIONS OF LLANDEILO AND BALA AGE
i. The Builth Volcano--ii. The Volcanoes of Pembrokeshire--iii. The Caernarvonshire Volcanoes of the Bala Period--iv. The Volcanic District of the Berwyn Hills--v. The Volcanoes of Anglesey--vi. The Volcanoes of the Lake District; Arenig to close of Bala Period--vii. Upper Silurian (?) volcanoes of Gloucestershire.
The stratigraphical subdivisions of geology are necessarily more or less arbitrary. The sequence in the sedimentary deposits of one region always differs in some degree from that of adjoining regions. In drawing up a table of stratigraphical equivalents for separate countries, we must be content to accept a general parallelism, without insisting on too close an identity in either the character of the strata or the grouping of their organic remains. We need especially to guard against the assumption that the limit assigned to a geological formation in any country marks a chronological epoch which will practically agree with that denoted by the limit fixed for the same formation in another country. The desirability of caution in this respect is well shown by the vagueness of the horizons between the several subdivisions of the Lower Silurian system. So long as the areas of comparison are near each other, no great error may perhaps be committed if their stratigraphical equivalents are taken to have been in a broad geological sense contemporary. But in proportion as the element of distance comes in, there enters with it the element of uncertainty.
Even within so limited a region as the British Isles, this difficulty makes itself strongly felt. Thus, in the typical regions of Wales, the several subdivisions of the Lower Silurian strata are tolerably well marked, both by lithological nature and by fossils. But as they are followed into other parts of the country, they assume new features, sometimes increasing sometimes diminishing in thickness, changing their sedimentary character, and altering the association or range of their organisms. The subdivisions into which the geologist groups them may thus be vaguely defined by limits which, in different parts of the region, may be far from representing the same periods of time.
Hence, in trying to ascertain how far the volcanic eruptions of one area during the Silurian period may have been contemporary with those of another area, we must be content to allow a wide margin for error. It is hardly possible to adhere strictly to the stratigraphical arrangement, for the geological record shows that in the volcanic districts the sedimentary formations by which the chronology might have been worked out are not infrequently absent or obscure. It will be more convenient to treat the rest of the Lower Silurian formations as the records of one long and tolerable definite section of geological time, without attempting in each case to distinguish between the eruptions of the successive included periods, so long as the actual volcanic sequence is distinctly kept in view. I will therefore take the history of each district in turn and follow its changes from the close of the Arenig period to the end of Upper Silurian time. The stages in the volcanic evolution of each tract will thus be clearly seen.
Above the Arenig group with its voluminous volcanic records comes the great group of sediments known as the Llandeilo formation, in which also there are proofs of contemporaneous volcanic activity over various parts of the sea-floor within the site of Britain. We have seen that in the south of Scotland the eruptions of Arenig time were probably continued into the period of the Llandeilo rocks, or even still later into that of the Bala group. But it is in Wales that the history of the Llandeilo volcanoes is most fully preserved. A series of detached areas of volcanic rocks, intercalated among the Llandeilo sediments, may be followed for nearly 100 miles, from the northern end of the Breidden Hills in Montgomeryshire, by Shelve, Builth, Llanwrtyd and Llangadock, to the mouth of the Taf river. But some 35 miles further west another group of lavas and tuffs appears on the coast of Pembrokeshire, from Abereiddy Bay to beyond Fishguard. The want of continuity in these scattered outcrops is no doubt partly due to concealment by geological structure. But from the comparative thinness of the volcanic accumulations and their apparent thinning out along the strike it may be inferred that no large Llandeilo volcano existed in Wales. There would rather seem to have been a long line of minor vents which in the south-east part of the area appear to have only discharged ashes. Certainly, if we may judge from their visible relics, these eruptions never rivalled the magnitude of the discharges from the Arenig volcanoes that preceded, or the Bala volcanoes that followed them.
i. THE VOLCANO OF BUILTH AND ITS NEIGHBOURS
So far as the available evidence goes, the most important volcanic centre down the eastern side of Wales during the Llandeilo period was one which lay not far from the centre of the long line of vents just referred to. Its visible remains form an isolated tract of hilly ground, some seven miles long, and four or five miles broad, immediately north from the town of Builth. This area is almost entirely surrounded by unconformable Upper Silurian strata, so that its total extent is not seen, and may be much more considerable than the area now laid bare by denudation.
The volcanic rocks of Builth were first described in the "Silurian System." Murchison clearly recognized that they included some which were "evolved from volcanic apertures during the submarine accumulation of the Lower Silurian rocks," and also "unbedded volcanic masses which had been intruded subsequently, dismembering and altering all the strata with which they came in contact." These igneous rocks were mapped in some detail by the Geological Survey, and their general relations were expressed in lines of horizontal section. They were likewise described by Ramsay in the Catalogue of the Rock-specimens in the Jermyn Street Museum, specimens of them being displayed in that collection. The tuffs and lavas were distinguished, and likewise the intrusive "greenstones." But no attempt was made towards petrographical detail.
This interesting district has recently been studied by Mr. Henry Woods, who has grouped the igneous rocks in probable order of appearance, as follows:--1st, Andesites; 2nd, Andesitic ash; 3rd, Rhyolites; 4th, Diabase-porphyrite; and 5th, Diabase.
Some of the andesites are described as intrusive in the Llandeilo strata. The ash in its lower part contains numerous well-rounded pebbles of andesite, usually five or six inches in diameter, but sometimes having a length of two feet. It contains fossils (Orthis calligramma, Leptæna sericea, Serpulites dispar, etc.), and as it is overlain with shales containing Ogygia Buchii, it may be regarded as probably of Lower Llandeilo age. The rhyolites are feebly represented, and some of them may possibly be intrusive. Among them a nodular variety has been noticed, the nodules being solid throughout, varying up to two inches in diameter, and formed of microcrystalline quartz and felspar, with no trace of any radial or concentric internal arrangement. The diabase-porphyrite, the most conspicuous rock of the district, is intrusive in the andesites and ashes, and occurs in four separate masses or sills. The diabases are all intrusive and of later date than any of the other igneous rocks, and as they traverse also the Llandeilo shales, they are probably considerably later than the previous eruptions. But as they do not enter the surrounding Llandovery and Wenlock strata, they are regarded by Mr. Woods as of intermediate age between the time of the Llandeilo and that of the Upper Silurian formations.
About nine miles in a west-south-westerly direction from the southern extremity of the Builth volcanic area, another much smaller exposure of igneous rocks has been mapped by the Geological Survey at the village of Llanwrtyd. This tract is only about three miles long and half a mile broad. The volcanic rocks are represented as consisting of three or more bands of "felspathic trap" interstratified in the Lower Silurian strata, and folded into an anticline along the ridge of Caer Cwm. No published line of section runs across this ground, and the band of rock does not appear to have been described.
Seventeen miles to the south-west a still feebler display of intercalated volcanic material occurs in the Llandeilo formation near the village of Llangadock. The Geological Survey map represents one or more bands of ash associated with limestone, and thrown into a succession of folds. In the Horizontal Section (Sheet III. Section 3) a band, 100 to 200 feet thick, of "trappean ash" with fossils is shown among the shales, limestones and grits, and in the Catalogue of Rock-specimens the same rock is referred to as brecciated ash in connection with specimens of it in the Museum, which are described as not purely ashy, but containing many slate-fragments and broken felspar-crystals together with organic remains.
About twenty-four miles still further in the same south-westerly direction, two patches of "ash" are shown upon the Survey map, near the mouth of the river Taf. No description of these rocks is given.
ii. THE VOLCANOES OF PEMBROKESHIRE
In north-western Pembrokeshire, the observations of Murchison, De la Beche and Ramsay showed the existence of an important volcanic district, where numerous igneous bands are interstratified among the Lower Silurian rocks, over an area extending from St. David's Head for thirty miles to the eastward. On the maps of the Geological Survey, lavas, tuffs, sills and bosses were discriminated, but no description of these rocks was published. Since the publication of the Survey map very little has yet been added to our information on the subject.
There appear to have been at least three principal groups of vents. One may be indicated by the bands of "felspathic trap" which have been mapped as extending from near St. Lawrence for fourteen miles to the east. Another must have existed in the neighbourhood of Fishguard. A third is shown to have lain between Abereiddy Bay and Mathry, by the abundant bands of lava and tuff and intrusive sills there to be seen.
Of these areas the only one which has yet been examined and described in some detail is that of Fishguard, of which an account has recently been published by Mr. Cowper Reed. This observer has shown that the eruptions began there during the deposition of the Lower Llandeilo rocks, and continued intermittently into the Bala period. The earliest consisted of felsites and tuffs intercalated between Lower Llandeilo black slates containing Didymograptus Murchisoni, the tuffs themselves being sometimes fossiliferous. A second great volcanic belt, composed of felsitic lavas, breccias and tuffs, lies at the base of the Upper Llandeilo strata and shows the maximum of volcanic energy. The breccias are partly coarse agglomerates, which probably represent, or lie not far from, some of the eruptive vents of the time. A higher band of lavas and breccias appears to be referable to the Bala formation. The whole volcanic series is stated to thin out towards the south-west, so that the chief focus of eruption probably lay somewhere in the neighbourhood of Fishguard.
The lavas may all be included under the general term felsite. Their specific gravity ranges from 2·60 to 2·76, and their silica percentage from 68 to 72. Mr. Cowper Reed observed among them three conspicuous types of structure. Some are characterized by a distinct arrangement in fine light and dark bands which rapidly alternate, and are sometimes thrown into folds and convolutions. A second structure, observed only at one locality, consists in the development of pale grey or whitish ovate nodules, about half an inch in length, with a clear quartz-grain in their centre, or else hollow. The third type is shown by the appearance of perlitic structure on the weathered surface.
The tuffs and breccias are chiefly developed at the base and top of each volcanic group. Some of them contain highly vesicular fragments, as well as pieces of slate and broken crystals of quartz and felspar.
A characteristic feature of this volcanic district is the occurrence in it of sills and irregularly-intruded masses of "greenstone." Under that name are comprised basalts, dolerites, andesitic dolerites with tachylitic modifications, as well as diabases and gabbros. Some of these rocks exhibit a variolitic structure. As regards age, some of the intrusions appear to have taken place before the tilting, cleavage and faulting of the strata. They have not been noticed in the surrounding Upper Silurian strata, and we may perhaps infer that here, as at Builth, they are of Lower Silurian date. Mr. Cowper Reed, however, is inclined to regard the large Strumble Head masses as later than the tilting and folding of the rocks.
A few miles to the south-west of the Fishguard district, on the coast of Abereiddy Bay, good sections have been laid bare of the volcanic rocks of this region. Dr. Hicks has shown that the bands of tuff there displayed are intercalated among the black slates of the Lower Llandeilo group, and that there was probably a renewal of volcanic activity during the deposition of the upper group. But the volcanic history of this area still remains to be properly investigated.
In southern Pembrokeshire two conspicuous bands of eruptive rocks have long been known and described. Their general characters and distribution were sketched by De la Beche, and further details were afterwards added by Murchison. As traced by the officers of the Geological Survey, they were represented as consisting of "greenstone," "syenite" and "granite." The more northerly band was shown to run in a nearly east and west line from Lawrenny to the Stack Rock, west of Talbenny, a distance of about fourteen miles. The second band, placed a short way farther south, stretches in the same general line, from Milford Haven at Dall Road into Skomer Island, a distance of about seven miles.
The relations of these rocks to the surrounding formations and their geological age have been variously interpreted. De la Beche regarded the different masses as intrusive, and probably later than even the adjoining Coal-measures. Murchison, on the other hand, considered the bedded eruptive rocks of Skomer Island to be undoubtedly lavas contemporaneous with the strata among which they are intercalated.
The rocks have been studied petrographically by various observers. Mr. Rutley gave a full description of the remarkable nodular and banded felsites of Skomer Island. Mr. Teall has also noticed these rocks, likewise "a magnificent series of basic lava-flows" in the same island, and a number of "porphyrites." The basic lavas seemed to him to contain too much felspar and too little olivine to be regarded as perfectly typical olivine-basalts, and he found them to lie sometimes in very thin and highly vesicular sheets. The "porphyrites" he placed "on the border-line between basic and intermediate rocks."
More recently this southern district of Pembrokeshire has been examined by Messrs. F. T. Howard and E. W. Small, who have obtained further evidence of the interbedded character of the igneous series. Below an upper basalt they have noted the occurrence of bands of felsitic conglomerate, sandstone, shale and breccia lying upon and obviously derived from a banded spherulitic felsite, below which comes a lower group of basalts. The age of this interesting alteration of basic and acid eruptions has not been precisely determined, but is conjectured to be that of the Bala or Llandovery rocks.
iii. THE CAERNARVONSHIRE VOLCANOES OF THE BALA PERIOD
Owing to the effects partly of plication and partly of denudation, the rocks of the next volcanic episode in Wales, that of the Bala period, occupy a less compact and defined area than those of the Arenig group in Merionethshire. From the latter they are separated, as we have seen, by a considerable depth of strata, whence we may infer, with the Geological Survey, that the eruptions of Arenig, the Arans and Cader Idris were succeeded by a long period of repose, the Llandeilo outbreaks described in the foregoing pages not having extended apparently into North Wales. When the next outbreaks took place, the vents are found to have shifted northwards into Caernarvonshire, where they fixed themselves along a line not much to the east of where the Cambrian porphyries and tuffs now appear at the surface. The lavas and ashes that were thrown out from these vents form the highest and most picturesque mountains of North Wales, culminating in the noble cone of Snowdon. They stretch northwards to Diganwy, beyond Conway, and southwards, at least as far as the neighbourhood of Criccieth. They die out north-eastwards beyond Bala Lake, and there can be but little doubt that they thin out also eastwards under the Upper Bala rocks. The lavas and tuffs that rise up on a similar horizon among the Bala rocks of the Berwyn Hills evidently came not from the Snowdonian vents, but from another minor volcanic centre some miles to the east, while still more remote lay the vents of the Breidden Hills and the sheets of andesitic tuff that probably spread from them over the ground east of Chirbury (Map II.).
The Caernarvonshire volcanic group extends from north to south for fully thirty miles, with an extreme breadth of about fifteen miles; while, if we include the rocks of the Lleyn peninsula, the area will be prolonged some twenty miles farther to the south-west.
The general stratigraphical horizon of this volcanic group has been well determined by the careful mapping of Ramsay, Selwyn and Jukes on the maps of the Geological Survey. These observers brought forward ample evidence to show that the lavas and tuffs were erupted during the deposition of the Bala strata of the Lower Silurian series, that the Bala Limestone is in places full of ashy material, and that this well-marked fossiliferous band passes laterally into stratified volcanic tuffs containing the same species of fossils. But the progress of stratigraphical geology, and the increasing value found to attach to organic remains as marking even minor stratigraphical horizons, give us reason to believe that a renewed and still more detailed study of the Bala rocks of North Wales would probably furnish data for more precisely defining the platforms of successive eruptions, and would thus fill in the details of the broad sketch which Sir Andrew Ramsay and his associates so admirably traced. Besides the Bala Limestone there may be other lithological horizons which, like the Garth grit and the pisolitic iron-ore of the Arenig group, might be capable of being followed among the cwms and crests as well as the opener valleys of Caernarvonshire. Until some such detailed mapping is accomplished, we cannot safely advance much beyond the point where the stratigraphy was left by the Survey.
From the Survey maps and sections it is not difficult to follow the general volcanic succession, and to perceive that the erupted materials must altogether be several thousand feet in thickness from the lowest lavas in the north to the highest on the crest of Snowdon. In that mountain the total mass of volcanic material is set down as 3100 feet. But this includes only the higher part of the whole volcanic group. Below it come the lavas of Y Glyder-Fach, which, according to the Survey measurements, are about 1500 feet thick, while still lower lie the ancient coulées of Carnedd Dafydd and those that run north from the vent of Y-foel-frâs, which must reach a united thickness of many hundred feet. We can thus hardly put the total depth of volcanic material at a maximum of less than 6000 to 8000 feet. The pile is, of course, thickest round the vents of discharge, so that no measurement, however carefully made at one locality, would be found to hold good for more than a short distance.
Though little is said in the Survey Memoir of the vents from which this vast amount of volcanic material was erupted, the probable positions of a number of these orifices may be inferred from the maps. From the shore west of Conway a series of remarkable eminences may be traced south-westwards for a distance of nearly forty miles into the peninsula of Lleyn. At the northern extremity of this line stands the prominent boss of Penmaen-mawr, while southward beyond the large mass of Y-foel-frâs, with the smaller knobs west of Nant Francon, and the great dome of Mynydd-mawr, the eye ranges as far as the striking group of puy-like cones that rise from the sea around Yr Eifl and Nevin. Some of these hills, particularly Y-foel-frâs, were recognized by the Survey as vents. But the first connected account of them and of their probable relation to the volcanic district in which they occur has been given by Mr. Harker in his exceedingly able essay on "The Bala Volcanic Series of Caernarvonshire,"--the most important contribution to the volcanic history of Wales which has been made since the publications of the Geological Survey appeared. I shall refer to these vents more specially in the sequel. I allude to them here for the purpose of showing at the outset the marvellous completeness of the volcanic records of Caernarvonshire. So great has been the denudation of the region that the pile of lavas and tuffs which accumulated immediately around and above these orifices has been swept away. No trace of any portion of that pile has survived to the west of the line of bosses; while to the east, owing to curvature and subsequent denudation, the rocks have been dissected from top to bottom, until almost every phase of the volcanic activity is revealed.
The volcanic products discharged from these vents consist of a succession of lava-streams separated by bands of slate, tuff, conglomerate and breccia. These fragmental intercalations, which vary from a few yards to many hundred feet in thickness, are important not only as marking pauses in the emission of lava or in the activity of the volcanoes, but as affording a means of tracing the several lavas to their respective vents. Essentially, however, the volcanic materials consist of lava-flows, the intercalations of fragmentary materials, though numerous, being comparatively thin. The thickest accumulation of tuffs is that forming much of the upper part of Snowdon. It is set down by my predecessor at 1200 feet in thickness, but I should be inclined to reduce this estimate. I shall have occasion to show that the summit and upper shoulders of Snowdon are capped with andesites interstratified among the tuffs. Sir Andrew Ramsay has referred with justice to the difficulty of always discriminating in the field between the fine tuffs and some of the lavas. Yet I am compelled to admit that, if the ground were to be re-mapped now, the area represented as covered by fragmental rocks would be considerably restricted. Mr. Harker is undoubtedly correct when he remarks that, taken "as a whole, the Bala volcanic series of Caernarvonshire is rather remarkable for the paucity of genuine ashes and agglomerates."
The lavas of the Bala volcanic group, like those of the Arenig series, were mapped by the Survey as "porphyries," "felstones," or "felspathic traps." They were shown to be acid-lavas, having often a well-developed flow-structure comparable with that of obsidian and pitchstone, and to consist of successive sheets that were poured out over the sea-floor. Their petrography has subsequently been studied more in detail by many observers, among whom I need only cite Professor Bonney, Professor Cole, Mr. Rutley, Mr. Teall, and Miss Raisin; the most important recent additions to our knowledge of this subject having been made by Mr. Harker in the Essay to which I have just referred.
The great majority of these lavas are thoroughly acid rocks, and present close analogies of composition and structure to modern rhyolites, though I prefer to retain for them the old name of "felsites." Their silica-percentage ranges from 75 to more than 80. To the naked eye they are externally pale greyish, or even white, but when broken into below the thick decomposed and decoloured crust, they are bluish-grey to dark iron-grey, or even black. They break with a splintery or almost conchoidal fracture, and show on a fresh surface an exceedingly fine-grained, tolerably uniform texture, with minute scattered felspars.
One of their most striking features is the frequency and remarkable development of their flow-structure. Not merely as a microscopic character, but on such a scale as to be visible at a little distance on the face of a cliff or crag, this structure may be followed for some way along the crops of particular flows. The darker and lighter bands of devitrification, with their lenticular forms, rude parallelism and twisted curvature, have been compared to the structure of mica-schist and gneiss. One aspect of this structure, however, appears to have escaped observation, or, at least, has attracted less notice than it seems to me to deserve. In many cases it is not difficult to detect, from the manner in which the lenticles and strips of the flow-structure have been curled over and pushed onward, what was the direction in which the lava was moving while still a viscous mass. By making a sufficient number of observations of this direction, it might in some places be possible to ascertain the quarter from which the several flows proceeded. As an illustration, I would refer to one of the basement-felsites of Snowdon, which forms a line of picturesque crags on the slope facing Llanberis. The layers of variously-devitrified matter curl and fold over each other, and have been rolled into balls, or have been broken up and enclosed one within the other (Fig. 55). The general push indicated by them points to a movement from the westward. Turning round from the crags, and looking towards the west, we see before us on the other side of the deep vale of Llyn Cwellyn, at a distance of little more than three miles, the great dome-shaped Mynydd-mawr, which, there is every reason to believe, marks one of the orifices of eruption. It might in this way be practicable to obtain information regarding even some of the vents that still lie deeply buried under volcanic or sedimentary rocks.
That these felsites were poured forth in a glassy condition may be inferred from the occurrence of the minute perlitic and spherulitic forms so characteristic of the devitrification of once vitreous rocks. Mr. Rutley was the first who called attention to this interesting proof of the close resemblance between Palæozoic felsites and modern obsidians, and other observers have since confirmed and extended his observations.
Another remarkable aspect of the felsites is that nodular structure so often to be seen among them, and regarding the origin of which so much has already been written. I agree with Professor Cole and Mr. Harker in looking upon the "nodules" as derived from original spherulites by a process of alteration, of which almost every successive stage may be traced until the original substance of the rock has been converted into a flinty or agate-like material. If this be the true explanation of the structure, some of the original lavas must have exhibited perlitic and spherulitic forms on a gigantic scale. There can, I think, be little doubt that this peculiar structure was very generally misunderstood by the earlier observers, who naturally looked upon it as of clastic origin, and who therefore believed that large beds of rock consisted of volcanic conglomerate, which we should now map as nodular felsite (pyromeride).
While by far the larger proportion of the Caernarvonshire lavas consists of thoroughly acid rocks, the oldest outflows are much less acid than those erupted at the height of the volcanic activity, when the rocks of Snowdon were poured forth. But towards the close of the period there was apparently a falling off in the acidity of the magma, for at the top of the group the andesitic lavas to which I have already alluded are encountered. Sir Andrew Ramsay has shown the existence of an upper "felstone" or "felspathic porphyry," almost entirely removed by denudation, but of which outliers occur on Crib-goch, Lliwedd, and other crests around Snowdon, and likewise on Moel Hebog. Mr. Harker alludes to these remnants, and speaks of them as less acid than the older lavas, but he gives no details as to their structure and composition. In an examination of Snowdon I was surprised to find that the summit of the mountain, instead of consisting of bedded ashes as hitherto represented, is formed of a group of lava-sheets having a total thickness of perhaps from 100 to 150 feet (6 in Fig. 56). The apex of Yr Wyddfa, the peak of Snowdon, consists of fossiliferous shale lying on a dull grey rock that weathers with elongated vesicles, somewhat like a cleaved amygdaloid, but a good deal decomposed. A thin slice of this latter rock shows under the microscope irregular grains and microlites of felspar, with a few grams of quartz, the whole much sheared and calcified. Below this bed comes a felsite, or devitrified obsidian, showing in places good spherulitic structure, and followed by a grey amygdaloid. The latter is a markedly cellular rock, and, though rather decayed, shows under the microscope a microlitic felspathic groundmass, through which granules of magnetite are dispersed.
1. Grits and slates; 2. Felsite with good flow-structure; 3. Volcanic tuffs; 4. Felsite; 5. Tuffs with sheets of felsite and andesite; 6. Group of andesitic lavas on summit of Snowdon; 7. Intrusive "greenstones."]
Underneath this upper group of lavas lie the tuffs for which Snowdon has been so long celebrated. But, as I have already stated, there does not appear to me to be such a continuous thickness of fragmental material as has been supposed. There cannot, I think, be any doubt that not only at the top, but at many horizons throughout this supposed thick accumulation of tuff, some of the beds of rock are really lava-flows. Some of these lavas have suffered considerably from the cleavage which has affected the whole of the rocks of the mountain, while the results of centuries of atmospheric disintegration, so active in that high exposed locality, have still further contributed to alter them. They consequently present on their weathered faces a resemblance to the pyroclastic rocks among which they lie. Where, however, the lavas are thicker and more massive, and have resisted cleavage better, some of them appear as cellular dull grey andesites or trachytes, while a few are felsites. Many instructive sections of such bands among the true tuffs may be seen on the eastern precipices of Snowdon above Glas-lyn.
It thus appears that the latest lavas which flowed from the Snowdonian vent were, on the whole, decidedly more basic than the main body of felsites that immediately preceded them. They occur also in thinner sheets, and are far more abundantly accompanied with ashes. At the same time it is deserving of special notice that among these less acid outflows there are intercalated sheets of felsite, and that some of these still retain the spherulitic structure formed by the devitrification of an original volcanic glass.
Far to the south-west, in the promontory of Lleyn, another group of volcanic rocks exists which may have been in a general sense contemporaneous with those of the Snowdon region, but which were certainly erupted from independent vents. Mr. Harker has described them as quartzless pyroxene-andesites, sometimes markedly cellular, and though their geological relations are rather obscure, he regards them as lava-flows interbedded among strata of Bala age and occurring below the chief rhyolites of the district. If this be their true position, they indicate the outflow of much less highly siliceous lavas before the eruption of the acid felsites. In the Snowdon area any such intermediate rocks which may have been poured out before the time of the felsitic outflows have been buried under these.
The tuffs of the Bala series in Caernarvonshire have not received the same attention as the lavas. One of the first results of a more careful study of them will probably be a modification of the published maps by a reduction of the area over which these rocks have been represented. They range from coarse volcanic breccias to exceedingly fine compacted volcanic dust, which cannot easily be distinguished, either in the field or under the microscope, from the finer crushed forms of felsite. Among the oldest tuffs pieces of dark blue shale as well as of felsite may be recognized, pointing to the explosions by which the vents were drilled through the older Silurian sediments already deposited and consolidated. Sometimes, indeed, they recall the dark slate-tuffs of Cader Idris, like which they are plentifully sprinkled with kaolinized felspar crystals. The beds of volcanic breccia intercalated between the lower felsites of Snowdon include magnificent examples of the accumulation of coarse volcanic detritus. The blocks of various felsites in them are often a yard or more in diameter. Among the felsite fragments smaller scattered pieces of andesitic rocks may be found. This mixture of more basic materials appears to increase upwards, the highest ashes containing detritus of andesitic lavas like those which occur among them as flows.
The tuffs in the upper part of Snowdon are well-bedded deposits made up partly of volcanic detritus and partly of ordinary muddy sediment. Layers of blue shale or slate interstratified among them indicate that the enfeebled volcanic activity marked by the fine tuffs passed occasionally into a state of quiescence. As is well known, numerous fossils characteristic of the Bala rocks occur in these tuffs. The volcanic discharges are thus proved to have been submarine and to have occurred during Bala time.
I have already alluded to some of the probable vents from which the lavas and tuffs were discharged, and to their position along a line drawn from Penmaen-mawr into the peninsula of Lleyn. It will be observed that they lie outside the area of the bedded volcanic rocks and rise through parts of the Silurian system older than these rocks. The largest and most important of them is unquestionably that formed by Y-foel-frâs and its neighbouring heights. As mapped by the Geological Survey, this mass of igneous rock is irregularly elliptical, measures about six square miles in area, and consists mainly of intrusive "felstone-porphyry" passing into "hornblendic greenstone." Mr. Harker, however, has made an important correction of this petrography, by showing that a large part of the area consists of augitic granophyre, while the so-called "greenstone" is partly diabase and partly andesitic ashes and agglomerates. He suggests that an older vent has here been destroyed by a later and larger protrusion of igneous matter. This high and somewhat inaccessible tract of ground is still in need of detailed mapping and closer study, for undoubtedly it is the most important volcanic vent now visible in North Wales. My former colleague in the Geological Survey, Mr. E. Greenly, spent a week upon it some years ago, and kindly supplied me with the following notes of his observations:--"The central and largest area of the neck is mainly occupied with diabases and andesites, while the ashes and agglomerates, which are intimately connected with them, seem to run as a belt or ring round them, and to occur in one or more patches in the midst of them. Portions of green amygdaloid run through the pyroclastic masses. Outside the ring of agglomerate and ashes an interrupted border of felsite can be traced, which may be presumed to be older than they, for a block of it was observed in them. The granophyre, on the other hand, which is interposed between the fragmental masses and the surrounding rocks on the western wall of the vent, seems to be of later date. Dykes or small bosses of diabase, like the material of the sills, pierce both the agglomerates and the rocks of the centre."
No agglomerate appears to have been noticed by any observer among the other supposed vents along the line that runs south-westwards from Penmaen-mawr, to the promontory of Lleyn. These bosses are rudely circular in ground-plan and rise vertically out of the Lower Silurian or Cambrian strata, or partake more of the nature of lenticular sheets or laccolites which have been thrust between the planes of bedding. There is usually an observable alteration of the surrounding rocks along the line of contact.
The material of these bosses is sometimes thoroughly acid, as is the granophyre of Y-foel-frâs, the microgranite of Mynydd-mawr with its riebeckite crystals, the augite-granite-porphyry of Clynog-fawr, and the granophyric and rhyolitic quartz-porphyries of the Rivals. In other cases the rock is of an intermediate grade, as in the enstatite-diorite of Penmaen-mawr, the pyroxene-andesite of Carn Boduan, and the quartz-augite-syenite of Llanfoglen. A few bosses of still more basic material occur in the Sarn district, including hornblende-diabase and hornblende-picrite. Sometimes both the acid and the more basic rocks are found in the same boss, as in the large mass of Y-foel-frâs.
It must be confessed that there is no absolute proof that any of these masses mark the actual sites of eruptive vents, except probably the boss of Y-foel-frâs. Some of them may have been intruded without establishing any outlet to the surface. But that a few of them really represent orifices from which the Bala volcanic group was erupted may be plausibly inferred from their neck-like form, from their positions with reference to the volcanic district, from the obvious thickening of the lavas and tuffs in the direction of these bosses, and from the petrographical relation that exists between their component materials and rocks that were discharged at the surface. This last-named feature has been well pointed out by Mr. Harker, who has established, by a study of microscopic slides, a gradation from the granophyric material of the bosses into structures greatly resembling those of the bedded felsites, and likewise a close similarity between the intermediate rocks of the other bosses and the andesites which have elsewhere been poured out at the surface. But perhaps the most impressive evidence as to the sites of the chief centres of eruption is supplied by the lavas and tuffs themselves as they thicken in certain directions and thin away in others. This feature of their distribution has been well expressed in the maps and sections of the Survey, and has been clearly summarized by Mr. Harker. The oldest lavas now visible lie at the northern end of the district, and the vents from which they proceeded may, with considerable probability, be placed somewhere in the tract which includes the chain of bosses of Penmaen-mawr, Y-foel-frâs, and Y Drosgl. The chief centre of eruption no doubt lay somewhere in the Snowdon tract, where the lavas and tuffs attain their greatest thickness, and whence they thin away in all directions. The Mynydd-mawr boss may be presumed to have been one of the main vents. But there were not improbably others, now concealed under the deep cover of their own ejections.
More diligent search, with a special eye to the discovery of such vents, might indeed be rewarded, even in the midst of the volcanic district itself. To the north-east of Capel Curig, for example, there is a prominent knob of agglomerate, which I visited with Mr. B. N. Peach, and which we regarded as probably marking one of the minor vents. The material of this eminence has a base which by itself would probably be regarded by the field-geologist as a felsite. But through this compact matrix are dispersed abundant stones of all sizes up to six inches or more in diameter. They are mostly subangular or somewhat rounded-off at the edges, and generally markedly cellular. Among them may be observed pieces of trachyte, felsite, and a rock that is probably a devitrified pitchstone or obsidian. The vesicles in these stones are sometimes lined with an acicular zeolite. Traces of rude bedding can be detected, dipping at high angles. On the north-east side of the hill finer agglomerate is seen to alternate with ashy grits and grey shales, which, dipping E.N.E. at 20°-30°, pass under a group of felsites, one at least of which retains a very fine perlitic structure and evidently flowed as a true glass. Some of these lavas are full of enclosed pieces of various flinty cellular and porphyritic felsites and andesites or trachytes, like the stones which occur abundantly in the agglomerate. The connection of these bedded lavas and tuffs with the agglomerate-neck seems obvious.
The Caernarvonshire volcanic area furnishes another admirable example of the intrusion of basic sills as a final phase of eruptivity. These masses have been carefully separated out on the maps of the Geological Survey, which present a striking picture of their distribution and their relation to the other igneous rocks. An examination of the maps shows at once that the basic sheets tend to lie parallel with the bedding along certain horizons. In the southern and western portions of the area they have forced themselves among the Lower Silurian sedimentary strata that underlie the Bala volcanic group--a position analogous to that taken by the corresponding sills of the Arenig series. But they likewise invade the volcanic group itself. Along the eastern borders of the district they abound, especially in the higher parts of the volcanic pile, where they have been injected between the flows, and have subsequently participated in the abundant plication of the rocks between the mountains and the line of the River Conway.
The curvatures into which the rocks of the region have been thrown, and the consequent breadth of country over which the volcanic sheets can now be examined, furnish a much better field than Merionethshire for the attempt to trace the probable centre or centres from which the basic magma of the sills was protruded. A study of the Survey maps soon leads to a conviction that the intrusions were not connected, except perhaps to a trifling extent, with the great line of western vents. It is remarkable that the older strata which emerge from under the volcanic group on its western outcrop are, on the whole, singularly free from sills, though some conspicuous examples are shown opposite to Mynydd-mawr, while a few more occur further north along the same line. Their lenticular forms, their short outcrops, and their appearance on different horizons at widely separated points seem to indicate that the sills probably proceeded from many distinct subterranean pipes. Their greater abundance along the eastern part of the district may be taken to indicate that the ducts lay for the most part considerably to the eastward of the line of western vents. They may have risen in minor funnels, like that of Capel Curig.
It is noteworthy that so abundant an extravasation of basic material should have taken place without the formation of numerous dykes. We have here a repetition of the phenomena that distinguished the preceding Arenig volcanic period in Merionethshire, and it will be remembered that the Llandeilo eruptions of Builth were likewise followed by the injection of large bodies of basic rock. As an enormous amount of igneous magma may thus be impelled into the Earth's crust without the formation of dykes, it is evident that the conditions for the production of sills must be in some important respects different from those required for dykes.
No evidence has yet been obtained that any one of these sills established a connection with the surface. Not a trace can be found of the outpouring of any such basic lava-streams, nor have fragments of such materials been met with in any of the tuffs. On the other hand, there is abundant proof of the usual contact-metamorphism. Though the sills conform on the whole to the bedding, they frequently break across it. They swell into thick irregular masses, and thin out rapidly. In short, they behave as true intrusive sheets, and not as bedded lavas.
In regard to their internal character, they show the customary uniformity of texture throughout each mass. They are mapped under the general name of "greenstones" by the Geological Survey, and are described in the Memoir as hornblendic. The more precise modern methods of examination, however, prove them to be true diabases, in which the felspar has, as a rule, consolidated before the augite, giving as a result the various types of diabasic structure.
The date of the intrusion of these basic sills can be fixed by the same process of reasoning as was applied to those of the Arenig volcanic group. Their connection with the other igneous rocks of Caernarvonshire is so obvious that they must be included as part of the volcanic history of the Bala period. But they clearly belong to a late stage, perhaps the very latest stage, of that history. They probably could not have been injected into their present positions, unless a considerable mass of rocky material had overlain them. Some of them are certainly younger than the tuffs of Snowdon and Moel Hebog, which belong to a late part of the volcanic period. On the other hand, they had been intruded before the curvature and compression of the region, for they share in the foldings and cleavage of the rocks among which they lie. The terrestrial movements that produced this disturbance have been proved to have occurred after the time when the uppermost Bala rocks were deposited, and before that of the accumulation of the Upper Silurian formations. The epoch of intrusion is thus narrowed down to some part of the Upper Bala period. With this subterranean manifestation, volcanic action in this part of the country finally died out.
iv. THE VOLCANIC CENTRE OF THE BERWYN HILLS
Among the thick group of sedimentary formations which overlies the great volcanic ridge of the Arans and Arenig, and undulates eastwards across the Bala Valley, occasional thin intercalations of tuff point to the existence of another centre of volcanic activity which lay somewhere in the region of the Berwyn Hills. The structure of this ground, first indicated by Sedgwick, was investigated in detail by J. B. Jukes and his colleagues, whose work was embodied in the Maps, Sections and Memoirs of the Geological Survey. The distinguishing characteristics of the volcanic rocks of this district are the occurrence of both lavas and tuffs as comparatively thin solitary bands in the midst of the ordinary sediments, and the persistence of these bands for a distance of sometimes more than 24 miles. The position of the vent or vents from which this extensive outpouring of volcanic material took place has not been revealed. As the bands tend to thin away eastwards, it may be surmised that the chief focus of eruption lay rather towards the west, perhaps under the trough of Upper Silurian strata somewhere in the neighbourhood of Llandderfel. There was probably another in the Hirnant district.
The mapping of the officers of the Survey showed that in the Berwyn Hills there are representatives of both the great volcanic periods of North Wales. A lower series of "felstones and greenstones" probably belongs to the older period, which began towards the end of Cambrian time and lasted in some districts even into the time of the Llandeilo formation. An upper group of tuffs, lying among the Bala rocks, is evidently equivalent, on the whole, to the much thicker volcanic series of the Snowdon region.
The lowest visible volcanic rocks occur among the hills to the north-west of Llanrhaiadr yn Mochnant. They are described as consisting of felstone of a pale greenish-grey colour and compact texture, like those of Arenig, and ashes distinctly interstratified with the slates. No exact petrographical examination of these rocks has yet been made. From the account given in the Survey Memoir there appears to be here a group of lavas and tuffs intercalated in Llandeilo perhaps partly in Upper Arenig, strata which form the broken dome of the Berwyn anticline. The lavas are represented as lying on four or five platforms, a single band reaching a thickness of 300 feet and separated from the next band by sometimes 1000 or 1500 feet of non-volcanic sediment.
These lower lavas, according to the measurements of Jukes, are overlain by more than 4000 feet of sedimentary strata before the upper or Bala volcanic series is reached. Three successive "ash-beds" constitute this upper series. Of these the lowest band, about 50 or 60 feet thick, was named a "greenstone ash" in contradistinction to a felstone ash, and was not traceable for more than a short distance. Above it, after an intervening thickness of several hundred feet of sedimentary strata, comes a second and much more continuous band of tuff, known as the "Lower ash-bed," about 100 feet thick on the west front of the Berwyn range. Still higher, after an interval of about 1500 feet of slates, lies the "Upper ash-bed," which on the same line of section has a thickness of about 200 feet. This is the most persistent of all the volcanic horizons, for it can be followed continuously round the whole range of the Berwyns until it is overlain by the Carboniferous Limestone near Selattyn, a distance of not less than twenty-four miles. The same band, but much more feebly developed, has been traced through the faulted country on both sides of Bala Lake, where it formed a useful platform in the investigation of the complicated geological structure of that area. Along the north side of the Berwyn Hills another thin band of tuff lies from 150 to 200 feet still higher up in the series, and has been traced for a distance of about twelve miles. The Bala limestone comes in about 800 or 1000 feet above the "Upper ash-bed."
L, Llandeilo Flags; B, Bala group; B L, Bala Limestone; t t, volcanic tuffs; D, intrusive "greenstones."]
Besides the rocks now enumerated, the Survey maps show the intercalation of four or five sheets of "greenstone," which are represented as following with marked regularity the strike of the strata. Until these sheets have been more precisely examined it is impossible to decide regarding their true petrographical character, or to determine whether they are sills, or interstratified lavas, or include rocks of both these types.
V. THE VOLCANOES OF ANGLESEY
We now turn to another part of the country, about which much has been written and keen controversy has arisen. In the centre of Anglesey, among the rocks grouped together by the Geological Survey as "altered Cambrian," there occur masses of breccia, the probable volcanic origin of which was, so far as I know, first suggested by Professor Hughes. Dr. Callaway regards them as pre-Cambrian, while Professor Blake places them in his "Monian system." When I went over them some years ago, I accepted the view that they are volcanic agglomerates. Subsequent examination, however, has convinced me that notwithstanding their remarkable resemblance to true agglomerates they are not really of volcanic origin, but are essentially "crush-conglomerates," like those in the Isle of Man, so well described by Mr. Lamplugh.
But though their present coarse, agglomerate-like structure is, I think, entirely due to the mechanical crushing of the rocks in situ and not to volcanic explosions, it does not follow that the rocks which have been broken up do not contain evidence of volcanic action contemporaneous with their original formation. Obviously, pyroclastic materials may be subjected to deformation and disruption as well as any other components of the earth's crust, and may be equally converted into crush-conglomerates. And in Anglesey it can, I think, be shown that some of the rocks which have been broken up were originally tuffs and volcanic breccias.
Throughout Anglesey the stratified rocks present evidence of having undergone very great compression, deformation and rupture. Thus at Llanerchymedd thick-bedded Lower Silurian grits, with their intercalations of shale, have been broken up by numerous small faults, and have been pushed over each other in large irregular blocks, the shales being now pinched out, and now pressed up into the interstices between the dislocated harder and more resisting grits. This condition of rupture may be regarded as one of the stages towards the formation of a conglomerate by the crushing together of rocks in situ. A few miles further south at the beginning of the railway cuttings of Llangefni, green, red and purple slates and grits appear in a rather more crushed state, and immediately beyond these strata come the coarse breccias. Neither in their composition nor in their structural condition do these Llangefni strata appear to be marked off from the undoubted Lower Silurian rocks as parts of a different system.
The railway cuttings at Llangefni reveal a series of rocks which appear to have been originally shales, with thin bands of siliceous grit. The argillaceous portions of this series are now green and phyllitic, and remind one of the finer parts of some basic tuffs among the older Palæozoic systems. They include, however, pale flinty bands, such as might have been derived from fine felsitic dust. The grits are for the most part fine-grained and highly siliceous, but they include also coarser varieties with clear quartz-grains. The enormous deformation which these strata have undergone is at once apparent. They seem to have been plicated, ruptured and thrust over each other, the harder parts surviving longest, but being eventually broken into small fragments. Every stage may be traced from a recognizable band of grit down to the rounded or elliptical pebbles of the same material entirely isolated in this phyllitic matrix of crushed shale.
But while the volcanic origin of these coarsely-fragmental masses cannot be maintained, there is elsewhere evidence that the older Palæozoic rocks of Anglesey include relics of contemporaneous volcanic eruptions. Seven miles to the south-east of Holyhead, in the basal Lower Silurian conglomerates which, as before referred to, Mr. Selwyn found lying unconformably on the green schists, there occur abundant fragments of volcanic rocks, besides the prevalent detritus of the schists of the neighbourhood. Some of the bands have somewhat the character of volcanic breccias or tuffs, and they show an evident resemblance to portions of the Bangor group and the rocks of Llyn Padarn, though they are doubtless of much later age. That these volcanic fragments were not derived from the waste of rocks of a much earlier period is made tolerably certain by the intercalation of true tuffs among the black shales higher up in the order of succession. Here, then, we have evidence of contemporaneous volcanic action in the very basement Lower Silurian strata of Anglesey, which by their fossil contents are shown to be on the horizon of the lowest Arenig or even Tremadoc group.
But still further and fuller evidence of Silurian volcanism is to be obtained by an examination of the northern coast-line. I have already referred to the elliptical fault which is marked on the Geological Survey map as running from the north-western headland to the eastern coast beyond Amlwch. The necessity for inserting this fault, apart from any actual visible trace of its occurrence, arose when the conclusion was arrived at that the rocks of the extreme north of Anglesey were essentially altered Cambrian strata. For immediately to the south of these rocks black shales, obviously Silurian, were seen to dip to the north--a structure which could only be accounted for by a dislocation letting them down into that position. The same necessity for a fault has of course been felt by all writers who have subsequently treated the northern area as pre-Cambrian. But it is deserving of notice that in the original mapping of the Survey no continuous abrupt hiatus is shown by the line which was afterwards marked as a continuous line of fault. On the contrary, on one of the field-maps in, I believe, Mr. Selwyn's handwriting the remark occurs:--"The gradual passage from the black shale to the upper green gritty slates of Llanfechell is best seen at Bothedd, on road from Llanfaethlu to Llyn-llygeirian."
It is no part of my aim to disprove the existence of faults along the line referred to. These may quite well exist; but there is assuredly no one gigantic displacement, such as the theory I am combating would require; while any faults which do occur cannot be greatly different from the others of the district, and do not prevent the true relations of the rocks from being discoverable.
Where the supposed elliptical fault reaches the shore at Carmel Point, the two groups of rock seem to me to follow each other in unbroken sequence. The black slates, which are admittedly Lower Silurian, dip underneath a breccia and greenish (Amlwch) slates. Not only so, but bands of similar black slates occur higher up, interstratified with and shading-off into tuffs and greenish slates. Further, bands of coarse volcanic breccia occur among the black slates south of the supposed break. These, in accordance with the exigencies of theory, are represented as separated by a network of faults from the black slates amid which they lie. But good evidence may be found that they are truly interbedded in these slates. In short, the whole of the rocks in that part of Anglesey form one great series, consisting partly of black slates, partly of greenish slates, with abundant intercalations of volcanic detritus. The age of the base of this series is moreover determined by the occurrence of Bala fossils in a band of limestone near Carmel Point.
The rocks which extend eastward along the coast from the north-western headland of Anglesey are marked on the Survey map as "green, grey and purple slates with conglomeratic and siliceous beds." The truly volcanic nature of a considerable proportion of these strata has been clearly stated by Mr. Blake. As they dip in a general northerly direction, higher portions of the series present themselves as far as the most northern projection of the island near Porth Wen (Fig. 58). They have been greatly crumpled and crushed, so that the slates pass into phyllites. They include some thick seams of blue limestone and white quartzite, also courses of black shale containing Lower Silurian graptolites. Among their uppermost strata several (probably Bala) fossils, including Orthis Bailyana, have been obtained by Professor Hughes. It has been supposed that the higher bands of black shale may also have been brought into their present positions by faults, and that they do not really belong to the series of strata among which they lie. But this suggestion is completely disproved by the coast-sections, which exhibit many thin interstratified leaves of black shale, sometimes less than an inch thick. These and the ashy layers containing the Orthis and other fossils form an integral part of the so-called "Amlwch slates."
As evidence of the regular intercalation of the black shales and tuffs in this sedimentary series, a portion of the coast section at Porth Wen is here given (Fig. 58). The lowest member (1) of the series is a white quartzite much jumbled in its bedding, but yet distinctly interstratified with the other sediments, and containing intercalated courses of green tuff and highly carbonaceous shale. Markings like worm-pipes are here and there to be seen. The next group of strata (2) consists of black shale followed by yellow conglomeratic sandstone and pebbly tuffs. The shales enclose rounded and angular fragments of quartzite. The sandstone passes upward into pinkish and yellowish conglomerate (3), with an abundant lustrous phyllitic matrix, which when free from pebbles closely resembles some of the tuffs of Llyn Padarn. The next band (4) is one of yellow, sandy, felspathic grit, quartz-conglomerate and fine tuffs, with leaves of dark shale towards the base. It was in the lower part of this band that the Orthis above mentioned was found. The black shales contain markings which are probably graptolites. Reddish quartzite and quartz-conglomerate (5) next succeed. These strata have the same phyllitic base just noticed. The highest group here shown is one of black, yellow and green shales mixed with patches and bands of volcanic breccia and tuff, the whole being greatly disturbed, cleavage and bedding seeming as it were to be struggling for the mastery. These last strata look as if they were about to pass up vertically into the ordinary dark Lower Silurian shales or slates.
There can be no doubt regarding the serious amount of crushing which the rocks of this coast-line have undergone. Some of the bands might even be described as "crush-conglomerates." Yet the intercalation of seams of black shale and limestone, and the occurrence of the exactly similar but thicker group of black shales at Porth Prydd, which are admitted to be Lower Silurian, unite the whole series of strata as parts of one formation.
It thus appears that the area coloured "altered Cambrian" on the Survey map, and regarded as pre-Cambrian by some later observers, is proved by the evidence of fossils at its base, towards its centre and at its top, to belong to the Lower Silurian series, probably to the Bala division. That this was the geological horizon of part at least of the area was recognized by Sir A. Ramsay, though he confessed himself unable "precisely to determine on the north coast of Anglesey how much of the strata are of Silurian and how much of Cambrian age." Professor Hughes was the first to suggest that the whole of these rocks should be referred to the Bala group.
Fig. 59.--Section of intercalated black shale in the volcanic series at Porth yr hwch, south of Carmel Point. ]
I have dwelt on the determination of the true geological age of the rocks of the north of Anglesey because of the diversity of opinion respecting them, and because of their great interest in regard to the history of volcanic action in Wales. These rocks contain a record of volcanic eruptions, probably contemporaneous on the whole with those of the Bala period in Caernarvonshire, yet independent of them and belonging to a different type of volcanic energy. Some of the vents probably lay in the north-western part of Anglesey. The materials ejected from them were, so far as we know, entirely of a fragmentary kind. Vast quantities of detritus, largely in the form of fine dust, were thrown out; but no trace has yet been found of the outflow of any lava. The lower part of this volcanic series consists of bedded breccias which are sometimes remarkably coarse. Their included stones, ranging up to six inches or more in diameter, are usually more or less angular, and consist mainly of various felsites. Layers of more rounded pebbles occasionally occur, while the bedding is still further indicated by finer and coarser bands, and even by intercalations of fine tuffs and ashy shales. Towards their upper limits some of these volcanic bands shade off into pale grey or greenish ashy shale, followed by black sandy shale of the usual kind. The relation of the peculiar greenish shale of the Amlwch type to these tuffs and breccias is well shown east of Carmel Point. This shale is interleaved with tuff and contains frequent repetitions of finer or coarser volcanic breccia, as well as occasional seams of black shale. An illustration of this structure is given in Fig. 59, where some yellow decomposing breccias (1), cut by a fault (f), are overlain by about 40 or 50 feet of black shale (2), above which lies a flinty felsitic rock (3) that appears to run in bands or dykes through the agglomerate. At Carmel Point (Fig. 60) a similar structure may be observed to that at Llyn Padarn already referred to (p. 163). The cleavage, which is well developed in the green slates (a), is much more faintly marked in the overlying breccia (b), but the bedding can still be detected in both rocks running parallel to their mutual boundary-line. Beyond Porth Padrig, which lies east from Carmel Point, the section may be seen which is shown in Fig. 61. Here the blue or lead-coloured shale or slate (a) marked as Silurian on the Geological Survey map passes up into a mass of fine yellowish felsitic tuff and breccia (b). The shale at the junction intercalates in thin leaves with the tuff.
The breccias south of Carmel Point, though they are chiefly made up of felsitic detritus, sometimes show a preponderance of fragments of shale. They vary also rapidly in texture and composition. These variations may indicate that the vent or vents from which their materials were derived stood somewhere in the near neighbourhood, if indeed they are not to be recognized in some of the boss-like eminences that rise above the shore. At the same time, the enormous amount of crushing and shearing which the rocks of this region have undergone has doubtless introduced crush-conglomerates into the structure of the ground. And some patient labour may be required before the nature and origin of the different fragmental masses are determined.
Certain remarkably coarse, tumultuous breccias, exposed on the coast at Mynyddwylfa and Cemmaes, were formerly regarded by me as volcanic agglomerates. But more recent examination has satisfied me that these, like the breccias at Llangefni, are not of volcanic origin but are crush-conglomerates.
While the lower breccias are sometimes tolerably coarse, the volcanic detritus becomes much finer in the higher parts of the Amlwch slates. Above the limestones and black shales of Cemmaes volcanic breccias and ashes, with limestone, quartzite, conglomerate and thin seams of black shale, continue to the extreme northern headlands. The amount of fine volcanic detritus distributed through these strata is very great. We can clearly make out that while ordinary sedimentation was in progress, an almost constant but variable discharge of fragmental materials took place from the vents in the neighbourhood. Sometimes a special paroxysm of explosion would give rise to a distinct band of breccia or of tuff, but even where, during a time of comparative quiescence, the ordinary sand or mud predominated, it was generally mingled with more or less volcanic dust.
Some bands of conglomerate in this group of strata deserve particular notice. The most conspicuous of these, already referred to as seen at Porth Wen, is made up of quartz and quartzite blocks, embedded in a reddish matrix largely composed of ashy material, and recalling the red spotted tuffs of Llyn Padarn. The occurrence of strong conglomerates near the top of a volcanic series has been noted at St. David's, Llyn Padarn and Bangor. In none of these localities, as I have tried to show, do the conglomerates mark an unconformability or serious break between two widely-separated groups of rock. The Anglesey section entirely supports this view, for the conglomerates are there merely intercalations in a continuous sequence of deposits; they are succeeded by tuffs and shales like those which underlie them. The interposition of such coarse materials, however, may undoubtedly indicate local disturbance, connected, perhaps, in this and the other localities, with terrestrial readjustments consequent upon the waning of volcanic energy.
The detailed geological structure of Anglesey is still far from being completely understood. Besides the serious crushing here referred to, there is reason to suspect that considerable plication, perhaps even inversion, of the strata has taken place, and that, by denudation, detached portions of some of the higher groups have been left in different parts of the island. The occurrence of Upper Silurian fossils in several localities adds to the perplexity of the problem by indicating that, among the folds and hardly distinguishable from the older slates, portions of Upper Silurian formations may have been caught and preserved. These difficulties, moreover, involve in some obscurity the closing phases of volcanic activity in Wales; for until they are, to some extent at least, removed, we shall be left in doubt whether the vents in the north of Anglesey, which were in eruption probably during Bala time, were the last of the long succession of Welsh volcanoes. If the black shales of Parys Mountain are really referable to the horizon of the Mayhill Sandstone, the two great igneous bands between which they lie would seem to mark an outbreak of volcanic energy during Upper Silurian time. No other indications, however, of eruptions of that age having been met with in Great Britain (though they occur in the south-west of Ireland and possibly in Gloucestershire), more careful investigation is required before such a position can be safely assigned to any rocks in Anglesey.
Putting these doubtful rocks aside for the present, we may, in conclusion, contrast the type of eruption in Anglesey with that of the great Snowdonian region. While the Caernarvonshire volcanoes were pouring forth their volumes of felsitic lava, and piling them up for thousands of feet on the sea-floor, the northern Anglesey vents, not more than some five-and-twenty miles away, threw out only stones and dust, but continued their intermittent explosions until they had strewn the sea-bottom with detritus to a depth of many hundred feet.
There is yet another feature of interest in this independent group of submarine vents in Anglesey. Their operations appear to have begun before the earliest eruptions of the Bala volcanoes in Caernarvonshire. Their first beginnings may, indeed, have been coeval with the explosions that produced the older Arenig tuffs of Merionethshire; their latest discharges were possibly the last manifestations of volcanic energy in Wales. They seem thus to bridge over the vast interval from Tremadoc to Upper Bala, possibly even to Upper Silurian time. But we may, perhaps, connect them with the still earlier period of Cambrian volcanism. I have referred to the evidence which appears to show that the vents whence the lavas and tuffs of Moel Trefan and Llyn Padarn were erupted gradually moved northwards, and continued in eruption until after the beginning of the deposition of the black slates that are generally regarded as Arenig. The Anglesey tuffs and breccias may thus be looked upon as evidence of a still further shifting of the active orifices northward. In this view, while the Aran and Cader Idris volcanoes broke out in Upper Cambrian and continued through Arenig time, and the Snowdonian group was confined to Bala time, a line of vents opened to the north-west in the Cambrian period before the epoch of the Llanberis slates, and, dying out in the south, continued to manifest a minor degree of energy, frequently discharging fragmental materials, but no lava, over the sea-bottom, until, towards the close of the Bala period, possibly even in Upper Silurian time, they finally became extinct.
vi. THE VOLCANOES OF THE LAKE DISTRICT (ARENIG TO CLOSE OF BALA PERIOD)
From the time of the appearance of Sedgwick's classic letters to Wordsworth, no volcanic area of Britain has probably been so well known in a general sense to the ordinary travelling public as the district of the English Lakes. Many geologists have since then visited the ground, and not a few of them have published additions to our knowledge respecting what is now known as the Borrowdale Volcanic Series. The most elaborate and detailed account of any part of it is that given by the late Mr. J. C. Ward in the Geological Survey Memoirs, wherein he embodied the results of his minute investigation and mapping of the northern portion of the district. Notices of the petrography of some of the more interesting rocks have subsequently been published by Mr. Rutley, Professor Bonney, Mr. Harker, Mr. Marr, Mr. Hutchings and others. But up to the present time no complete memoir on the volcanic geology of the Lake District as a whole has appeared. The sheets of the Geological Survey map present a graphic view of the general distribution of the rocks, but so rapid has the progress of certain branches of geology been since these sheets were published, that the map is even now susceptible of considerable improvement.
In estimating the area over which the volcanic rocks of the Lake District are spread, geologists are apt to consider only the tract which lies to the south of Keswick and stretches southward to a line drawn from the Duddon Sands to Shap. But it can easily be shown that this area falls far short of the extent of that wherein the rocks can still be traced, and yet further short of that over which the lavas and ashes originally spread. For, in the first place, the volcanic group can be followed round the eastern end of the mountain-group which culminates in Skiddaw, and along the northern base of these heights to Cockermouth, though only a narrow fringe of it emerges from underneath the Carboniferous series. It is thus manifest that the volcanic rocks once stretched completely across Skiddaw and its neighbours, and that they extend northwards below the Whitehaven Coal-field. But, in the next place, far beyond these limits, volcanic rocks, which there can be little doubt were originally continuous with those of the Lakes, emerge from beneath the base of the Cross Fell escarpment, and still further to the east a prolongation of the same group rises for a brief space to the surface from under the great limestone sheets of Upper Teesdale. Between the north-western and south-eastern limits within which the rocks can now be seen there intervenes a distance of some 11 miles, while the extreme length of the tract from south-west to north-east is about 50 miles. Even if we take these figures as marking the approximate boundaries of the region covered by the volcanic ejections, it cannot be less than 550 square miles. But this is probably much less than the original area.
The thickness of the accumulated volcanic materials is proportionate to the large tract of country over which they have been spread. From various causes, it is difficult to arrive satisfactorily at any precise statement on this question. In a volcanic series bedding is apt to be obscure where, as in the present case, there are no interstratified bands of ordinary sedimentary strata to mark it off. It tends, moreover, to vary considerably and rapidly within short distances, not only from subsequent unequal movements of subsidence or elevation, but from the very conditions of original accumulation. Mr. Ward considered that the maximum thickness of the volcanic group of the Lake District might be taken to range from 12,000 to 15,000 feet. Professors Harkness and Nicholson, on the other hand, gave the average thickness as not more than 5000 feet. My own impression is that the truth is to be found somewhere between these two estimates, and that the maximum thickness probably does not exceed 8000 or 9000 feet. In any case there cannot, I think, be much doubt that we have here the thickest accumulation of volcanic material, belonging to a single geological period, anywhere known to exist in Britain.
The geological age of this remarkable volcanic episode is fortunately fixed by definite palæontological horizons both below and above. The base of the volcanic group rests upon and is interstratified with the upper part of the Skiddaw Slate, which from the evidence of its fossils is paralleled with the Arenig rocks of Wales. The highest members of the group are interstratified with the Coniston Limestone, which, from its abundant fauna, can without hesitation be placed on the same platform as the Bala Limestone of Wales, and is immediately followed by the Upper Silurian series. Thus the volcanic history comprises the geological interval that elapsed between the later part of the Arenig period and the close of the Bala period. It begins probably not so far back as that of the Arenig group of Merionethshire, and its termination was perhaps coincident with the dying out of the Snowdonian volcanoes. But it contains no record of a great break or interval of quiescence like that which separated the Arenig from the Bala eruptions in Wales.
The materials that form this enormous volcanic pile consist entirely of lavas and ashes. No intercalations of ordinary sedimentary material have been met with in it, save at the bottom and at the top. The lower lavas, well seen among the hills to the south of Keswick, were shown by Mr. Ward to be intermediate between felsites and dolerites in regard to their silica percentage, and he proposed for them the name of felsi-dolerites. They are comprised in the group of the andesites or "porphyrites." From the analyses published by Mr. Ward, the amount of silica appears to range up to about 60 per cent. They are usually close-grained, dull dark-grey to black rocks, breaking, where fresh, with a splintery or conchoidal fracture, showing a few minute striated felspars, apt to weather with a pale-brown or yellowish-grey crust, and sometimes strongly vesicular or amygdaloidal. They present many external resemblances to some of the "porphyrites" or altered andesites of the Lower Old Red Sandstone of Scotland. A microscopic examination of specimens collected by Dr. Hatch and myself from the hills to the south of Keswick showed the rocks to be true andesites, composed of a multitude of slender laths (sometimes large porphyritic crystals) of felspar with a brownish glassy groundmass, and with some chloritic material probably representing augite, but with no trace of quartz.
Another type of andesite has been found by Mr. Hutchings to occur abundantly at Harter Fell, Mardale, between the Nan Bield Pass and High Street, and in the cliffs on the right side of the Kentmere Valley. It consists of rocks mostly of a grey-green or grey-blue colour with resinous lustre and extremely splintery fracture. They are augite-andesites of a much more vitreous nature than the dominant type of lavas of the Lake District. Their groundmass under the microscope is seen to have originally varied from a wholly glassy base to an intimate mixture of glass and exceedingly minute felspar-microlites. This groundmass is permeated with chlorite in minute flakelets, and encloses numerous porphyritic sharply-defined felspar-crystals, together with chlorite-pseudomorphs after augite. Gradations from these rocks to the ordinary more coarse-grained andesites may be observed.
Some of the andesites appear to have a trachytic facies, where the felspars of the groundmass consist largely of untwinned laths and appear to be mainly orthoclase.
Among the lavas of the Lake District there occur many which are decidedly more basic than the andesites, and which should rather be classed among the dolerites and basalts, though they do not appear to contain olivine. These rocks occur at Eycott Hill, above Easedale Tarn, Scarf Gap Pass, Dale Head, High Scawdell, Seatoller Fell and other places. Analyses of those from Eycott Hill were published by Mr. Ward, and their silica percentage was shown to range from 51 to 53·3. The microscopic characters of the group have been more recently determined by Mr. Hutchings and Messrs. Harker and Marr.
The andesitic and more basic lavas are particularly developed in the lower and central part of the volcanic group. They rise into ranges of craggy hills above the Skiddaw Slates, and form, with their accompanying tuffs, the most rugged and lofty ground in the Lake District. They extend even to the southern margin of the volcanic area at one locality to the south-west of Coniston, where they may be seen with their characteristic vesicular structure forming a succession of distinct flows or beds, striking at the Coniston Limestone which lies upon them with a decided, though probably very local, unconformability. One of the flows from this locality was found by Dr. Hatch, under the microscope, to belong to the more basic series. It approaches a basalt, containing porphyritic crystals of fresh augite instead of the usual felspars, and showing a groundmass of felspar microlites with some granules of augite and dispersed magnetite. This local increase of basic composition is interesting as occurring towards the top of the volcanic group. A porphyritic and somewhat vesicular andesite, with large crystals of striated felspar in a dark almost isotropic groundmass, occurs under the Coniston Limestone near Stockdale.
Mr. Ward was much impressed with the widespread metamorphism which he believed all the volcanic rocks of this region had undergone, and as a consequence of which arose the difficulty he found in discriminating between close-grained lavas and fine tuffs. There is, of course, a general induration of the rocks, while cleavage has widely, and sometimes very seriously, affected them. There is also local metamorphism round such bosses as the Shap granite, but the evidence of any general and serious metamorphism of the whole area does not seem to me to be convincing.
With regard to the original structure and subsequent alteration of some of the andesitic lavas, an interesting section has recently been cut along the road up Borrowdale a little south of the Bowder Stone. Several bands of coarse amygdaloidal lava may there be seen interstratified among tuffs. The calcite amygdales in these rocks are arranged parallel to the bedding and therefore in the planes of flow, while those lined with chlorite are more usually deformed parallel to the direction of the cleavage. This difference suggests that before the cleavage took place, not improbably during the volcanic period, the rocks had been traversed by heated water producing internal alteration and rearrangements, in virtue of which the vesicles along certain paths of permeation were filled up with calcite, so as then to offer some resistance to the cleavage, while those which remained empty, or which had been merely lined with infiltrated substance, were flattened and pulled out of shape. Messrs. Harker and Marr have shown that the amygdaloidal kernels had already been introduced into the cellular lavas before the intrusion of the Shap granite. In the account to be given of the Tertiary plateau-basalts (Chapter xxxvi.) evidence will be adduced that this filling up of the steam-cavities of lava may take place during a volcanic period, and that it is probably connected with the passage of heated vapours or water through the rocks.
Though acid lavas are not wholly absent from the central and lower parts of the volcanic group, it is at the top that their chief development appears to occur. These rocks may be grouped together as felsites or rhyolites. They probably play a much larger part in the structure of the southern part of the volcanic area than the published maps would suggest, and a detailed survey and petrographical study of them would well reward the needful labour. A fine series of felsites is interbedded in the lower part of the Coniston Limestone, and spreads out underneath it along the southern margin of the volcanic district from the Shap granite south-westward for some miles (Fig. 62). Between the valleys of the Sprint and Kent these felsites (which farther east are said to be 700 feet thick) may be seen interposed between the limestone and the fossiliferous calcareous shales below it, while from underneath the latter other sheets rise up into the range of hills behind.
a, Felsites more or less cleaved; b, Calcareous shales with fossils, much cleaved; c, Cleaved felsite; d, Coniston Limestone; e, Stockdale Shales (with graptolites).]
These acid lavas are generally grey, cream-coloured, or pink, with a white weathered crust. Their texture when fresh is flinty or horny, or at least extremely fine-grained and compact. They are seldom markedly porphyritic. They frequently display good flow-structure, and sometimes split up readily along the planes of flow. Occasionally the flow-lines on the outer crust have broken up in the movement of the rock, giving rise to irregular fragments which have been carried forward. Short, extremely irregular, branching veins of a fine cherty felsitic substance, which occasionally shows a well-marked flow-structure parallel to the walls, traverse certain parts of a dark-grey felsite, near Brockstones, between the valleys of the Kent and Sprint. Occasionally a distinct nodular structure may be observed in these acid lavas, sometimes minute, like an oolite, in other parts, as on Great Yarlside, presenting large rounded balls. This nodular structure is not confined to the lava-flows, but has been detected by Messrs. Harker and Marr in what appears to be an intrusive rock near Shap Wells. The microscopic characters of some of the Lake District rhyolites were described by Mr. Rutley, who found them to exhibit beautiful perlitic and spherulitic structures. That such rocks as these were poured out in a vitreous condition, like obsidian or pitchstone, cannot be doubted. Chemical analysis shows that the Lake District rhyolites agree exactly with those of North Wales in their composition. They contain about 76 per cent of silica.
The rhyolitic lavas have been seriously affected by the general cleavage of the region. In some places they have been so intensely cleaved as to become a kind of fissile slate, and there seems good reason to believe that in this altered condition they have often been mistaken for tuffs. Where they assume a nodular structure, the nodules have sometimes been flattened and elongated in the direction of the prevalent cleavage.
The abundance and persistence of thoroughly acid lavas along the southern edge of the volcanic area where the youngest outflows are found, is a fact of much interest and importance in the history of the eruptions of this region. It harmonizes with the observations made in Wales, where in the Arenig, and less distinctly in the Bala group, a marked increase in acidity is noticeable in the later volcanic products. At the same time, as above mentioned, there is evidence also of the discharge of more basic materials towards the close of the eruptions, and even of the outflow of a lava approaching in character to basalt.
According to the Geological Survey maps, by far the largest part of the volcanic district consists of pyroclastic materials. When my lamented friend, the late Mr. Ward, was engaged in mapping the northern part of the district, which he did with so much enthusiasm, I had an opportunity of going over some of the ground with him, and of learning from him his ideas as to the nature and distribution of the rocks and the general structure of the region. I remember the difficulty I had in recognizing as tuff much of what he had mapped as such, and I felt that had I been myself required, without his experience of the ground, to map the rocks, I should probably have greatly enlarged the area coloured as lava, with a corresponding reduction of that coloured as tuff. A recent visit to the district has revived these doubts. It is quite true, as Mr. Ward maintains, that where the finer-grained tuffs have undergone some degree of induration or metamorphism, they can hardly, by any test in the field, be distinguished from compact lavas. He was himself quite aware of the objections that might be made to his mapping, but the conclusions he reached had been deduced only after years of unremitting study in the field and with the microscope, and in the light of experience gained in other volcanic regions. Nevertheless I think that he has somewhat exaggerated the amount of fragmental material in the northern part of the Lake District, and that the mapping, so consistently and ably carried out by him, and followed by those members of the Survey who mapped the rest of the ground, led to similar over-representation there. Some portions of the so-called tuffs of the Keswick region are undoubtedly andesites; other parts in the southern tracts include intercalated bands of felsite as well as andesite.
But even with this limitation, the pyroclastic material in the Lake District is undoubtedly very great in amount. It varies in texture from coarse breccia or agglomerate, with blocks measuring several yards across, to the most impalpable compacted volcanic dust. In the lower parts of the group some of the tuffs abound in blocks and chips of Skiddaw Slate. Some good examples of this kind may be seen in Borrowdale, below Falcon Crag and at the Quayfoot quarries. Where the tuff is largely made up of fragments of dark blue slate, it much resembles the slate-tuffs of Cader Idris. Some of the pieces of slate are six or eight inches long and are now placed parallel to the cleavage of the rock. Among the slate debris, however, felspar crystals and felsitic fragments may be observed. Bands of coarser and finer green tuff show very clearly the bedding in spite of the marked cleavage (Fig. 63).
The highly-inclined fine lines show the cleavage. The more gently dipping bands and lines mark the bedding.]
But throughout the whole volcanic group the material of the tuff is chiefly of thoroughly volcanic origin, and its distribution appears to agree on the whole with that of the bedded lavas. In the older portions of the group it is probably mainly derived from andesitic rocks, though with an occasional intermingling of felsitic or rhyolitic detritus, while in the higher parts many of the tuffs are markedly rhyolitic. Among the lapilli minute crystals of felspar, broken or entire, may be detected with the microscope. Some of the ejected ash must have been an exceedingly fine dust. Compacted layers of such material form bands of green slates, which may occasionally be seen to consist of alternations of coarser and finer detritus, now and then false-bedded. Such tuffs bring vividly before the mind the intermittent explosions, varying a little in intensity, by which so much of the fabric of the Lake mountains was built up.
Breccias of varying coarseness are likewise abundant, composed of fragments of andesite and older tuffs in the central and lower parts of the volcanic group, and mainly of felsitic or rhyolitic detritus in the upper parts. Some of these rocks, wherein the blocks measure several yards across, are probably not far from the eruptive vents, as at Sourmilk Gill and below Honister Pass. Generally the stones are angular, but occasionally more or less rounded. Stratification can generally be detected among these fragmental rocks, but it is apt to be concealed or effaced by the cleavage, while it is further obscured by that widespread induration on which Mr. Ward has laid so much stress. The extreme state of comminution of the volcanic dust that went to form the tuffs has probably caused them to be more liable to metamorphism than the lavas.
Little has yet been done in identifying any of the vents from which the vast mass of volcanic material in the Lake District was ejected. Mr. Ward believed that the diabase boss forming the Castle Head of Keswick marks the site of "one of the main volcanic centres of this particular district," whence the great lava sheets to the southward flowed out. There are obviously two groups of bosses on the northern side of the district, some of which may possibly mark the position of vents. A few of them are occupied by more basic, others by more acid rocks. It is not necessary to suppose that the andesitic lavas ascended only from the former and the felsites from the latter. While the felsites on the whole are younger than the more basic lavas, they may have been erupted from vents which had previously emitted andesites, so that the present plug may represent only the later and more acid protrusions.
Besides the boss of Castle Head there are numerous smaller basic intrusions farther down the Derwent Valley on either side of Bassenthwaite Lake. Among these are the highly basic rocks forming the picrite on the east side of the Dash Beck and the dykes on Bassenthwaite Common. All these bosses, sills, and dykes rise through the Skiddaw Slates, but there is no positive proof that they belong to the Lower Silurian volcanic series; they may possibly be much later.
The most important and most interesting of all the intrusive masses of basic material is that which constitutes a large part of the eminence that culminates in Carrock Fell. The remarkable variations in the composition of this mass have been already referred to. Mr. Harker has shown that while the centre of the mass is a quartz-gabbro, it becomes progressively more basic towards the margin. Through the gabbro a mass of granophyre has subsequently made its way, and along the line of junction has incorporated into its own substance so much of the basic rock as to undergo a marked modification in its structure and composition. Whether these intruded bodies of basic and acid material have ascended in one of the old volcanic funnels and have been injected laterally in laccolitic fashion has not been ascertained. Mr. Harker, indeed, is rather inclined to refer the intrusions to a time not only later than the Borrowdale volcanoes, but later even than the terrestrial movements that subsequently affected the district and gave the rocks their present cleaved and faulted structures. Besides the gabbro and granophyre of this locality, igneous activity has manifested itself in the uprise of numerous later dykes and veins, intermediate to basic in composition. Some of these are glassy (tachylyte) and spherulitic or variolitic.
Throughout the Lake District a considerable number of bosses of more acid rocks rise through the Skiddaw Slates, and likewise through the volcanic group even up to its highest members. Some of these bosses may possibly indicate the site of volcanic vents. Two of them, which form conspicuous features on either side of the Vale of St. John, consist of microgranite, and rise like great plugs through the Skiddaw Slates, as well as through the base of the volcanic group. The view of the more eastern hill, as seen from the west, is at once suggestive of a "neck." These masses measure roughly about a square mile each.
With the acid intrusions may possibly be associated some of the other masses of granophyre, microgranite and granite (felsite, felstone, quartz-felsite, syenitic granite, quartz-syenite, elvanite), which have long attracted attention in this region. The largest of these intrusions is the tract of granite which stretches from Eskdale down to near the sea-coast as a belt about eleven miles long and from one to three miles broad. Another large mass is the granophyre or "syenite" of Ennerdale. Numerous other intrusions of smaller dimensions have been mapped.
To what extent any of these eruptive masses were associated with the volcanic phenomena remains still to be worked out. There seems to be little doubt that a number of them must belong to a much later period. Mr. Harker has expressed his belief that the intrusion of some of these igneous rocks was intimately associated with the post-Silurian terrestrial movements of which cleavage is one of the memorials. The Skiddaw granite, though it does not touch any part of the volcanic group, but is confined to the underlying Skiddaw Slates, was erupted after the cleavage of the district, which affects the volcanic as well as the sedimentary series. In other instances also, as in that of Carrock Fell, the intrusion seems to have been later than the disturbances of the crust. The amount of metamorphism around some of the bosses of granite is considerable. That of the Skiddaw region has been well described by J. C. Ward, while that of the volcanic group by the Shap granite has been carefully worked out by Mr. Harker and Mr. Marr.
The Shap granite comes through the very highest member of the volcanic series, and even alters the Upper Silurian strata. It must thus be of much younger date than the volcanic history of the Lake District. It presents some features in common with the granite bosses of the south of Scotland. Like these, it is later than Upper Silurian and older than Lower Carboniferous or Upper Old Red Sandstone time. Its protrusion may thus have been coeval with the great volcanic eruptions of the period of the Lower Old Red Sandstone. It will accordingly be again referred to in a later chapter.
It must be confessed that none of the large bosses of massive rocks, whether diabases, gabbros, felsites, granophyres, or granites, appear to afford any satisfactory proof of the position of the vents which supplied the lavas and tuffs of the Lake District. Nor can such a decided accumulation of the volcanic materials in certain directions be established as to indicate the quarters where the centres of eruption should be sought. On the contrary, the confused commingling of materials, and the comparative shortness of the outcrop of the several sheets which have been traced, rather suggest that if any one great central volcano existed, its site must lie outside of the present volcanic district, or more probably, that many scattered vents threw out their lavas and ashes over no very wide area, but near enough to each other to allow their ejected materials to meet and mingle. The scene may have been rather of the type of the Phlegræan fields than of Etna and Vesuvius. If this surmise be true, we may expect yet to recognize little necks scattered over the volcanic district and marking the positions of some of these vanished cones.
What appears to have been one of these small vents stands near Grange at the mouth of Borrowdale, where I came upon it in 1890. In the little Comb Beck, the Skiddaw Slates are pierced by a mass of extremely coarse agglomerate, forming a rudely-circular boss. The slates are greatly disturbed along the edges of the boss, so much so, indeed, that it is in some places difficult to draw a line between them and the material of the agglomerate. That material is made up of angular blocks, varying in size up to three feet long, stuck in every position and angle in an intensely-indurated matrix formed apparently of comminuted debris like the stones. The blocks consist of a finely-stratified shale, which is now hardened into a kind of hornstone, with some felsitic fragments. I could see no slags or bombs of any kind. There is no trace of cleavage among the blocks, nor is the matrix itself sensibly cleaved. I believe this to be a small volcanic neck and not a "crush-conglomerate." It has been blown through the Skiddaw Slates, and is now filled up with the debris of these slates. Its formation seems to have taken place before the cleavage of the strata, and its firm position and great induration enabled it to resist the cleavage which has so powerfully affected the slates and many members of the volcanic group.
It was the opinion of my predecessor, Sir Andrew Ramsay, and likewise of Mr. Ward, that the Cumbrian volcanic action was mainly subærial. This opinion was founded chiefly on the fact that, save at the bottom and top of the series, there is no evidence of any interstratified sediment of non-volcanic kind. The absence of such interstratification may undoubtedly furnish a presumption in favour of this view, but, of course, it is by no means a proof. Better evidence is furnished by the unconformability already mentioned between the Coniston Limestone and the lavas on which it lies. Besides angular pieces of lava, probably derived from direct volcanic explosion, this limestone contains fragments of amygdaloidal andesite, and also rolled crystals of striated felspar. These ingredients seem to indicate that some part of the volcanic group was above water when the Coniston Limestone was deposited.
The absence of interstratifications of ordinary non-volcanic sediment in the Borrowdale group might conceivably arise from the eruptions following each other so continuously on the sea-floor, and at so great a distance from land that no deposition of sand or mud from the outside could sensibly affect the accumulation of volcanic material. Certainly some miles to the east at the Cross Fell inlier, as already mentioned, there is evidence of the alternation of tuffs with the sandy and muddy sediment of the sea-bottom. Here, at the outer confines of the volcanic district, the ejected materials evidently fell on the sea-floor, mingled there with ordinary sediment, and enclosed the same organic remains. The well-defined stratification of many of the fine tuffs is rather suggestive to my mind of subaqueous than of subærial accumulation. At the same time, there seems no reason why, here and there at least, the volcanic cones should not have risen above the water, though their materials would be washed down and spread out by the waves.
One of the most marked points of contrast between the Cumbrian and the Welsh volcanic districts is to be found in the great paucity of sills in the former region. A few sheets of diorite and diabase have been mapped, especially in the lower parts of the volcanic group and in the underlying Skiddaw Slates. On the other hand, dykes are in some parts of the district not unfrequent, and certainly play a much more prominent part here than they do in the Welsh volcanic districts. The majority of them consist of felsites, quartz-porphyries, diorites, and mica-traps. But there is reason to suspect that where they are crowded together near the granite, as around Shap Fells, they ought to be connected with the uprise of the post-Silurian granitic magma rather than with the history of the volcanic group. If this series of dykes be eliminated, there remain comparatively few that can with any confidence be associated with the eruption of the Borrowdale rocks.
vii. UPPER SILURIAN (?) VOLCANOES OF GLOUCESTERSHIRE
A remarkable group of igneous materials has long been known to rise among the Silurian rocks of the Tortworth district at the north end of the Bristol coal-field. They were believed to be aqueous deposits in the Wernerian sense by Weaver. Murchison regarded them as intrusive sheets; Phillips looked on them as partly intrusive and partly interstratified. They consist largely of coarsely-amygdaloidal basalts, some of which have been microscopically examined. But their field-relations as well as their petrography have not yet been adequately determined. They are represented on the Geological Survey Map as forming a number of parallel bands in strata classed as Upper Llandovery. If, as seems probable, some of them are really interstratified, they form the youngest group of Silurian volcanic rocks in England, Scotland, or Wales.
The Ancient Volcanoes of Great Britain, Volume 1 (of 2) · The Wunder Library — complete classics, free to read, with narration.