Section Two

HISTORICAL EXPOSITION OF THE PROBLEM

FIRST ROUND

Sismondi-Malthus v. Say-Ricardo, MacCulloch

X. SISMONDI'S THEORY OF REPRODUCTION page 173

XI. MACCULLOCH v. SISMONDI 191

XII. RICARDO v. SISMONDI 203

XIII. SAY v. SISMONDI 211

XIV. MALTHUS 219

SECOND ROUND

The Controversy between Rodbertus and von Kirchmann

XV. V. KIRCHMANN'S THEORY OF REPRODUCTION page 227

XVI. RODBERTUS' CRITICISM OF THE CLASSICAL SCHOOL 238

XVII. RODBERTUS' ANALYSIS OF REPRODUCTION 252

THIRD ROUND

Struve--Bulgakov--Tugan Baranovski v. Vorontsov--Nikolayon

XVIII. A NEW VERSION OF THE PROBLEM page 271

XIX. VORONTSOV AND HIS 'SURPLUS' 276

XX. NIKOLAYON 284

XXI. STRUVE'S 'THIRD PERSONS' AND 'THREE WORLD EMPIRES' 292

XXII. BULGAKOV AND HIS COMPLETION OF MARX'S ANALYSIS 298

XXIII. TUGAN BARANOVSKI AND HIS 'LACK OF PROPORTION' 311

XXIV. THE END OF RUSSIAN 'LEGALIST' MARXISM 324