Part 11

I am of opinion, that if one had the misfortune of being reduced to the necessity of chusing between amputating at the upper part of the thigh, or at the articulation itself, one reason for prefering the latter, would be the greater ease there is in stopping the hemorrhage of the crural artery.

A surgeon and anatomist, who has been in repute, observes, That an hemorrhage of the crural artery is what is chiefly to be dreaded, but the operation requires too short a time, for such an hemorrhage to be fatal. It is surprizing to see him mention this operation as one that is very familiar; I make this remark, because, as he is not the only person who may allow himself to talk in this manner, a bold pretender to the art, on reading such a passage, might undertake an operation as easy and common, which has never yet been performed. TISSOT.

What Mr. Bilguer says with respect to the wounded Prussians, is but too applicable to those of every army.

SECT. XXX.

I ought now to say something concerning a contusion, or echymosis; I shall confine my remarks particularly to that kind where there is a great quantity of extravasated fluid diffused under the skin, such as we often see, when a ball, without breaking the skin, injures it to such a degree, that it looks like a mortified eschar, and at the same time dislocates, fractures, or shatters the bones belonging to the part. When a surgeon meets with a contusion of this kind, the treatment is not greatly different from that recommended in a mortification; for the skin must be treated exactly like a mortified slough, must be laid open by several deep incisions, dressed with the powder mentioned § X. covered with a digestive ointment mixed with a little essence of myrrh, and the part affected, as well as all around it, kept constantly bathed with emollient fomentations, without any ingredient, either stimulating or astringent. With regard to the shattered bones, the same method may be followed as in § XX. If any of them are luxated, they must be reduced, without, however, confining them by the bandages used in ordinary luxations, and which, in this case, would make the necessary incisions uneasy, would prevent the gangrenous sloughs from casting off, and hinder the formation of pus: It is therefore sufficient, after having replaced the bone, to let it remain quite undisturbed; and when the corrupted slough is come off, the sore may be dressed like wounds of the fleshy parts.

SECT. XXXI.

Some imagine that these violent contusions, accompanied with fractures, require amputation, as the properest method of cure. I shall mention, what seems to me strongly against this opinion. In the first place we must reflect, that the danger of dying, in these cases, does not arise solely from the fluids extravasated in the contused part, but from the violent concussion, which gives a shock, and occasions a general compression of the vessels over all the body, especially the internal ones; and from the vessels being compressed, obstructed or ruptured, proceed extravasation, inflammation and suppuration.

This commotion of the whole body, depends on the external air, which being compressed, condensed, and rapidly pushed on by a ball, moving with vast velocity, acts on the body with greater force, and causes a more violent contusion, than any other substance, even the heaviest has ever done. From thence proceed contusions of the viscera, spitting and vomiting of blood, oppression, cough, pains, inflammations and suppurations internally, a fever, and other complaints which happen after contusions, seemingly slight, and confined to some particular part, but which are, in fact, the consequences of this general, and what may be called invisible, contusion of the whole body.

The amputation of the limb does not remedy those accidents; on the contrary, it increases them, by means of the dread the patient feels at the thoughts of amputation, and by the excruciating pain which attends it; thus accelerating that death it was meant to prevent. I therefore boldly affirm, that amputation cannot be of service in those cases, wherein the nature of the parts and the state they are in, forbid it; that in many, it is hurtful, and hastens death; and that in others, even where the patient recovers, it is likewise improper, if he could be cured and the limb preserved; a surgeon is unpardonable who employs it in such a case.

FOOTNOTES:

Can it be called curing a limb to take it off altogether?

It has been known long since, that this concussion, or what may be called a general contusion, is one of the principal causes of the danger arising from gunshot wounds, and more or less from those of all kinds of fire arms; but at present I do not recollect to have seen the mechanism of this effect so well explained as in this performance. The rapidity with which the air strikes, compensates what it wants in density: Those who love to reduce every thing to calculation, will be able exactly to determine this effect by the rule of proportion: Supposing on one hand, a stream of air, which has acquired, by the motion of the ball, a given velocity, and which acts upon a man with this degree of velocity; supposing on the other hand, a man falling upon a floor, likewise with a given degree of velocity, the effect will be equal, if the velocity of air, is to the man who falls, as the density of the board is to that of the air; or, more briefly, if the contusing bodies be in an inverse ratio of their densities. I am even induced to believe, that when the velocity is augmented to a certain degree, its effect is augmented in a greater proportion than its increase; or, to speak algebraically, that its effects ought to be expressed by some quality of its degrees; thus the effect of a velocity of 150 degrees, would be to the effect of a velocity of 125, not as 150 : 125 or as 6 : 5 but as the square, or perhaps some other quality of 150, to the square or the correspondent quality of 125.

There are physical reasons that induce us to believe that the case is so, and there are several observations which seem to confirm it. Those who have served in time of war, have all been witnesses of some singular instance or other of the effects of the percussion of the air; there are instances of people killed on the field, without being touched by the ball. I was told by officers, men of veracity, that at the battle of Fontanoy, a ball broke the thigh bone of a soldier in the Dutch army, without touching him; another saw a man who was rendered paralytic on one side, by a ball whizing past him. Curious observers know, that nothing so greatly fatigues an army as a high wind, even the centinels are tired, without marching; the reason is, that a high wind occasions a kind of general contusion, which of course produces weariness. I do not know but some of the effects of lightening may be imputed to the same cause. I shall add nothing to what Mr. Bilguer says concerning the effects of a contusion; he is sufficiently explicit on this head; and as I have already treated the subject pretty largely in my book termed Advice to the People, I shall only observe, that in the wounds made by musket-ball, the effect of the general concussion is not very considerable, but the danger, in such cases, proceeds from the topical contusion accompanying the wound, the small quantity of blood commonly discharged from it; and lastly, as Mr. Le Dran remarks, because the instant a man receives a gunshot wound, he is struck with a sudden dread he cannot possibly resist. There seems to me to be three reasons for this dread, of which even the wounded person himself is not altogether conscious; in the first place, the idea that gunshot wounds are dangerous; secondly, because the degree of the hurt is not known; thirdly, the instantaneous effect of the concussion, which renders a man much more susceptible of fear. There is a point of time when courage is useless. I shall beg leave, in this place, to insert a case I had from the eye-witnesses, and which demonstrates the bad effect of apprehension on wounded patients. Two officers, in the service of France, were wounded in the last campaign but one; one of them very dangerously, the other, who had been a prisoner a little time before, and had been extremely ill used, but very slightly; they were carried to the same place, and lodged in the same apartment; the first expected to die, but nevertheless recovered in a short time; the second hoped to be cured very quickly, and his wound, a superficial one in the leg, did not discover the least sign of danger. The place they were in was surprized, and they were informed they were made prisoners; the idea of what he had suffered, made so strong an impression on the latter, that he instantly found himself indisposed; the following dressing the wound appeared mortified, every remedy proved useless, and he died in a few days. TISSOT.

The troublesome symptoms which I have here enumerated, happen seldomer when the limb is entirely carried off by the ball, although the concussion caused by the compression of the air must be greater in this case, than when the ball has only grazed; a circumstance which might induce one to call in question the justness of my remarks in this section. But these doubts will vanish, when we reflect, that in a contusion there is no discharge of blood, whereas it is very considerable in cases where the limb is intirely carried off; and thus, the remedy is here a consequence of the accident itself, since this hemorrhage effects what we would wish to effect by artificial bleeding; in contusions, where there is no discharge of blood, it removes obstructions, and disperses the extravasated humours, which are the consequences of concussion.

SECT. XXXII.

As I object to the amputation of contused limbs, it is reasonable I should point out the method of treating such contusions: I prevent the troublesome symptoms they produce, or disperse them if they have already appeared, by frequent bleedings, and by the exhibition of such medicines as attenuate the blood, resolve what is too gross, remove what is obstructed, and render fit to be reabsorbed what is extravasated. I join with them such as, by gently evacuating by stool, unload the vessels; and I afterwards give such things as brace up the fibres, and restore the natural crasis of the blood.

I have found no medicine more effectual to attenuate the blood, and resist the febrile disposition, than a powder, consisting of nitre, Epsom salt, cream of tartar, and true Armenian bole.

FOOTNOTES:

I have not experienced a better medicine in such cases, than the plentiful use of oxymel. TISSOT.

SECT. XXXIII.

The external applications for a contused limb should vary, according to circumstances, or according as the contusion has caused a mortified slough, or has not. If it has not, but nevertheless the bone is fractured, the applications should be of a very mild nature. In such a case I make no incisions, but I endeavour to bring the two ends of the bone together, to place them in their natural position, and to keep them in it, by means of compresses and bandages, as in the common simple fractures: I constantly stupe the whole dressings with discutient and vulnerary fomentations, and exactly follow the plan laid down § XIV. by which means I have almost always happily cured contusions of this kind.

If the contusion has caused a mortified slough, and has at the same time shattered the bone, we must begin by separating the dead slough from the sound parts, with a scalpel; we must make deep incisions, and neglect no means proper for promoting the discussion or suppuration; and the fracture of the bone must be treated agreeably to the method recommended § XXIV. This case requires great vigilance in the care of it, and we find ourselves amply recompensed for our labour, by the pleasure of accomplishing the cure of these unfortunate patients, either compleat, or at least as much so, as can possibly be obtained in their situation.

There is at present at the hospital at Torgau, a soldier who had been grievously wounded; the shoulder and arm were very bad, from the extravasation the contusion had occasioned; the scapula and clavicle were entirely shattered; the head of the os humeri dislodged from the glenoid cavity, and pushed downwards; the ligaments having been too violently stretched, now hung loose; and the neighbouring parts, deeply bruised, were covered with a black slough, like a mortification. The contusion and double fracture of the shoulder blade and clavicle are compleatly cured, the head of the os humeri never could be kept in its articulation, on account of the relaxation of the ligaments; the other symptoms are happily removed, but he has a cough, and almost constant fever, with its concomitant symptoms; whence we may conclude that matter is formed in some bowel, probably in the lungs, a consequence resulting from the contusion of the internal parts.

FOOTNOTES:

An infusion of water-germander, and yarrow in water, with the addition of about a sixth or eighth of vinegar, is one of the most proper fomentations in such cases. TISSOT.

SECT. XXXIV.

Every one will easily conceive, that this method of curing limbs that are wounded, fractured and shattered by gun-shot, such as I have been hitherto describing, is accompanied with a great deal of pain, and with murmurs and impatience on the part of the sick; that it requires a very judicious surgeon, and gives him abundance of trouble, care and anxiety; besides, I do not pretend that every patient was saved by it: The following lines are applicable on the occasion:

Non est in medico semper relevetur ut æger, Interdum docta plus valet arte malum.